This article was written by our expert who is surveying the industry and constantly updating the business plan for an auto repair shop.
Our business plan for an auto repair shop will help you build a profitable project
Starting an auto repair shop requires careful planning around insurance costs, which can range from $5,000 to $25,000 annually depending on your business model and location.
Insurance is one of the most critical expenses for any auto repair business, with mandatory coverage including general liability and workers' compensation, while optional policies like garagekeepers insurance protect customer vehicles in your care.
If you want to dig deeper and learn more, you can download our business plan for an auto repair shop. Also, before launching, get all the profit, revenue, and cost breakdowns you need for complete clarity with our auto repair shop financial forecast.
Auto repair shop insurance costs vary significantly based on business type, location, and coverage levels, with annual premiums ranging from $5,000 for small operations to over $25,000 for larger commercial facilities.
The most expensive states for auto repair insurance include Michigan, Louisiana, and Nevada, while Maine, New Hampshire, and Virginia offer the lowest rates, with premiums varying by more than 100% between states.
| Insurance Type | Annual Cost Range | Key Coverage Details |
|---|---|---|
| General Liability | $468-$1,068 | Covers third-party injuries, property damage, and legal costs for $1-2M policies |
| Workers' Compensation | $1,000-$10,000+ | Mandatory in most states; costs $2.15 per $100 of payroll for mechanics |
| Garagekeepers Insurance | $1,000-$1,300 | Protects customer vehicles from fire, theft, vandalism, and weather damage |
| Commercial Property | $500-$2,000+ | Covers building, tools, and equipment from various risks |
| Commercial Auto | $1,000-$2,500 | Required for business vehicles; cost per vehicle varies by use |
| Professional Liability | $800-$1,500 | Covers claims from faulty repairs or professional mistakes |
| Cyber Liability | $500-$1,200 | Protects against data breaches and digital record compromises |
What insurance is legally required for auto repair shops to operate in the United States?
Two types of insurance are absolutely mandatory for auto repair shops in the United States: general liability and workers' compensation insurance.
General liability insurance protects your auto repair business against third-party claims for bodily injury, property damage, and associated legal costs. This coverage is essential for all repair shops and is typically required by landlords if you're leasing space, or by lenders if you have business loans. The policy covers incidents like a customer slipping on oil in your shop or damage to nearby property from your operations.
Workers' compensation insurance is required in almost every state if you have employees working at your auto repair shop. This coverage pays for medical expenses and lost wages when mechanics or other staff members suffer work-related injuries or illnesses. Each state sets its own requirements, but most mandate coverage as soon as you hire your first employee.
Commercial auto insurance becomes mandatory if your repair shop owns any vehicles used for business purposes, such as tow trucks, parts delivery vans, or customer shuttle vehicles. The coverage requirements vary by state but typically include higher liability limits than personal auto policies.
State regulations can vary significantly, so it's crucial to check with your state's insurance commissioner or a licensed insurance agent to ensure you meet all local requirements for your auto repair business.
What optional insurance should auto repair shops consider and when?
Several optional insurance policies can provide crucial protection for auto repair shops depending on their specific operations and risk exposure.
Garagekeepers insurance is the most important optional coverage for repair shops, protecting customer vehicles while in your care, custody, or control. This policy covers damage from fire, theft, vandalism, weather events, and other perils. You should strongly consider this coverage if you keep customer vehicles overnight, offer long-term storage, or work on high-value vehicles.
Commercial property insurance protects your building, tools, diagnostic equipment, and inventory from risks like fire, theft, storms, and vandalism. This coverage becomes essential if you own your building or have invested significantly in specialized equipment. Even if you lease, you'll need coverage for your tools and equipment.
Professional liability insurance (also called errors and omissions) covers claims arising from faulty repairs or professional mistakes. This is particularly important if you offer specialized services like transmission rebuilds, engine diagnostics, or work on luxury vehicles where repair errors could lead to expensive claims.
Cyber liability insurance has become increasingly relevant as repair shops digitize customer records, process electronic payments, and store sensitive data. Consider this coverage if you maintain digital customer databases or use computerized diagnostic systems connected to the internet. This is one of the strategies explained in our auto repair shop business plan.
How much does general liability insurance typically cost for auto repair businesses?
General liability insurance for auto repair shops typically costs between $39 and $89 per month for standard coverage limits.
Most auto repair businesses pay approximately $468 to $1,068 annually for a general liability policy with coverage limits between $1 million and $2 million. The lower end of this range applies to smaller shops with minimal risk exposure, while larger operations or those in high-risk areas pay toward the upper end.
Many insurance providers report that small repair shops can secure basic general liability coverage for under $45 per month. This typically includes $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate limits, which meets most commercial lease and lending requirements.
The exact premium depends on several factors including your shop's size, annual revenue, claims history, and location. Shops in urban areas with higher crime rates or those offering specialized services like performance modifications typically face higher premiums.
Coverage limits significantly impact costs - upgrading from $1 million to $2 million in coverage can increase monthly premiums from $39 to $89 or more, depending on other risk factors specific to your auto repair operation.
What are typical workers' compensation costs for auto repair shops with employees?
Workers' compensation insurance for auto repair shops averages about $93 per month per employee, or approximately $2.15 for every $100 of payroll.
For a typical small to mid-sized repair shop with 7 mechanics earning a combined annual payroll of $364,000, the annual workers' compensation premium would be approximately $9,138. This breaks down to about $761 per month for the entire crew, though costs vary significantly based on your state's regulations and your shop's claims history.
States classify auto repair work as a moderate to high-risk occupation due to the physical nature of the work and potential for injuries from lifting, repetitive motions, and working with dangerous tools. This classification directly impacts your premium rates, with some states charging significantly more than others.
Your shop's claims history plays a crucial role in determining costs - shops with frequent injury claims face substantially higher premiums through experience rating modifications. Implementing strong safety programs and maintaining a clean claims record can reduce your workers' compensation costs by 20% or more over time.
Premium calculations also consider factors like whether mechanics work on heavy trucks versus passenger vehicles, the use of hydraulic lifts, and exposure to hazardous materials, all of which can increase or decrease your final costs.
What does garagekeepers insurance cover and what does it cost?
Garagekeepers insurance protects customer vehicles from damage while in your auto repair shop's possession, covering perils like fire, theft, vandalism, and severe weather.
| Coverage Type | What It Covers | What It Excludes |
|---|---|---|
| Comprehensive Coverage | Fire, theft, vandalism, weather damage, falling objects | Mechanical breakdown, faulty workmanship, normal wear |
| Specified Perils | Only listed perils like fire, explosion, theft, windstorm | Any peril not specifically named in the policy |
| Collision Coverage | Damage from impact with objects or other vehicles | Intentional damage, racing, off-road use |
| Storage Locations | Vehicles in your garage, parking lot, or designated areas | Vehicles driven off-premises for non-business purposes |
| Employee Actions | Accidental damage by employees during normal operations | Intentional damage, theft by employees, personal use |
| Parts & Equipment | Customer-owned parts installed or awaiting installation | Shop inventory, tools, or shop-owned equipment |
| Legal Defense | Defense costs for covered claims up to policy limits | Contractual liability, warranties, guarantees |
Annual costs for garagekeepers insurance typically range from $1,000 to $1,300, translating to roughly $83 to $108 per month. However, premiums can vary from $800 to $2,000 annually depending on your location, the types of vehicles you service, and your coverage limits.
Factors affecting your garagekeepers insurance costs include the maximum value of vehicles you work on, whether you offer storage services, your shop's security measures, and your claims history. Shops working on luxury or exotic vehicles face substantially higher premiums due to increased exposure.
How do coverage limits affect monthly premiums for auto repair shops?
Higher coverage limits directly increase your monthly insurance premiums, sometimes doubling or tripling costs when moving from basic to comprehensive coverage.
For general liability insurance, increasing your aggregate limit from $1 million to $2 million typically raises monthly premiums from around $39 to $89 or more. This represents a 128% increase in cost for double the coverage, though the exact increase varies based on your shop's risk profile and location.
The relationship between coverage limits and premiums isn't always linear - the jump from $2 million to $5 million in coverage might only increase premiums by 50% rather than 150%. This makes higher limits increasingly cost-effective for larger auto repair operations with more assets to protect.
Coverage limits affect different policies differently. For garagekeepers insurance, increasing your per-vehicle limit from $50,000 to $100,000 might add just $20-30 per month, while doubling your aggregate limit could add $100 or more monthly. You'll find detailed market insights in our auto repair shop business plan, updated every quarter.
Consider your actual exposure when selecting limits - a shop working on standard vehicles rarely needs the same coverage as one servicing luxury cars, and over-insuring wastes money that could be invested in growing your auto repair business.
What factors have the biggest impact on auto repair shop insurance costs?
Location ranks as the single most influential factor affecting auto repair shop insurance costs, with premiums varying by over 100% between states.
Shops in high-crime urban areas face significantly higher premiums due to increased theft and vandalism risks. Natural disaster exposure also impacts costs - repair shops in hurricane zones, flood plains, or earthquake-prone regions pay substantially more for property coverage. State regulations and legal environments further influence costs, with some states having much higher liability award averages.
Claims history serves as the second major cost driver for auto repair insurance. A single large claim can increase premiums by 20-50%, while multiple claims might make coverage difficult to obtain. Insurance companies use experience modification factors to adjust premiums based on your loss history compared to similar businesses.
Employee count and total payroll directly impact workers' compensation costs, which often represent the largest insurance expense for repair shops. More employees mean higher premiums, but the cost per employee may decrease with larger operations due to better safety programs and economies of scale.
The types of services offered significantly affect premiums - shops performing transmission work, engine rebuilds, or servicing commercial vehicles face higher liability exposure than those doing basic maintenance. Specialized equipment value, annual revenue, and years in business also play important roles in determining your final insurance costs.
How do insurance costs differ between mobile mechanics, home garages, and commercial facilities?
Insurance costs vary dramatically between different auto repair business models, with mobile mechanics often paying the highest rates despite having lower overhead.
| Business Type | Annual Insurance Cost | Primary Cost Drivers | Unique Risks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mobile Mechanic | $6,000-$12,000 | Vehicle liability, equipment theft, on-site work risks | Working in uncontrolled environments, tool theft from vehicle |
| Home-Based Garage | $3,000-$8,000 | Zoning issues, limited customer traffic, residential risks | Homeowner policy exclusions, neighbor complaints, limited coverage |
| Small Commercial Shop | $8,000-$15,000 | Property costs, employee coverage, customer volume | Higher liability exposure, equipment investment, lease requirements |
| Large Commercial Facility | $15,000-$50,000+ | Multiple employees, high-value equipment, extensive operations | Complex claims, environmental liability, multiple work bays |
| Dealership Service | $25,000-$75,000+ | Franchise requirements, luxury vehicles, warranty work | Manufacturer liability, high-value inventory, customer expectations |
| Specialty Shop | $10,000-$30,000 | Specialized equipment, unique services, expertise liability | Professional errors, limited parts availability, custom work |
| Fleet Maintenance | $20,000-$60,000 | Commercial vehicle exposure, contract liability, scale | Business interruption claims, commercial standards, tight deadlines |
Mobile mechanics face unique challenges with insurance costs due to increased liability from working at customer locations, higher theft risk for tools and equipment, and additional commercial auto coverage requirements. Their premiums often exceed those of fixed-location shops despite lower property costs.
Home-based garages may enjoy lower insurance costs initially, but face coverage gaps as many homeowner policies exclude business activities. Converting to proper commercial coverage while operating from home can be complex and may violate residential zoning laws, potentially leading to denied claims.
Which insurance companies offer the best coverage for auto repair businesses?
Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, and Nationwide consistently rank as top insurers for auto repair shops, offering specialized coverage and competitive rates.
Progressive Commercial leads the market with comprehensive garage liability policies specifically designed for auto repair operations. They offer flexible payment plans, online policy management, and specialized coverage for both small independent shops and larger operations. Their premiums typically run 10-15% below market average for shops with clean claims histories.
Travelers provides extensive risk management resources alongside their insurance products, including safety training programs and loss prevention consultations. Their garagekeepers coverage is particularly comprehensive, and they're known for handling claims efficiently. Premium rates are competitive, especially for established shops with multiple locations.
Liberty Mutual specializes in customizable policies that can grow with your auto repair business. They offer unique endorsements for diagnostic equipment, loaner vehicles, and environmental liability. Their premiums tend to be middle-of-the-road but offer excellent value through included services and coverage options.
Other highly-rated insurers include Zurich (excellent for larger operations), Allstate (strong small business focus), GEICO (competitive rates for new shops), and Auto-Owners (superior customer service). When comparing insurers, focus on industry expertise, claims handling reputation, and specific coverage for auto repair operations rather than just price.
What insurance should new auto repair shops prioritize with limited budgets?
Start with general liability and workers' compensation insurance as your non-negotiable foundation, then add coverage as your auto repair business grows.
These mandatory policies should consume about 40-50% of your initial insurance budget:
- General liability insurance ($500-$1,000 annually) - protects against customer injuries and property damage claims
- Workers' compensation (varies by payroll) - required as soon as you hire your first employee
- Commercial auto insurance ($1,000-$2,500 per vehicle) - mandatory for any business-owned vehicles
- Garagekeepers insurance ($1,000-$1,300 annually) - essential if storing customer vehicles overnight
- Basic property insurance ($500-$1,500) - covers your tools and equipment investment
Consider starting with lower coverage limits to reduce costs, then increasing them as revenue grows. A $1 million general liability policy often suffices initially, compared to the $2-5 million policies established shops carry.
Bundle policies with a single insurer to save 10-20% through multi-policy discounts. Many insurers offer business owner policies (BOPs) combining general liability and property coverage at reduced rates. Get expert guidance and actionable steps inside our auto repair shop business plan.
Delay purchasing professional liability, cyber insurance, and business interruption coverage until your second year unless specifically required by contracts or leases. Focus initial resources on building your customer base and reputation rather than over-insuring.
Which insurance add-ons are typically not worth the cost for auto repair shops?
Several insurance add-ons provide minimal value relative to their cost for most auto repair shops and should be avoided unless specific circumstances require them.
Crime insurance and employee dishonesty coverage often duplicate protections already included in general liability or property policies. Unless you handle large amounts of cash or have experienced internal theft, these add-ons rarely justify their $500-$1,000 annual cost. Most modern repair shops process payments electronically, reducing cash-related risks.
Inland marine insurance, designed to cover tools and equipment in transit, becomes unnecessary for shops that rarely transport equipment. If your tools stay at the shop, your property insurance already provides coverage. Mobile mechanics need this coverage, but stationary shops can skip it and save $300-$800 annually.
High-limit umbrella policies exceeding $5 million rarely benefit small to mid-sized repair shops. Unless you service exotic vehicles, have substantial assets to protect, or face unique liability exposures, the additional $2,000-$5,000 annual cost provides minimal practical benefit.
Business income insurance with extended periods beyond 30-60 days typically wastes money for repair shops, as most can resume operations quickly after covered losses. Equipment breakdown coverage also duplicates manufacturer warranties for newer equipment. Focus insurance spending on core coverages that address your auto repair shop's actual daily risks.
How much do auto repair shop insurance costs vary by location?
Insurance costs for auto repair shops can vary by more than 100% between states, with location being the single largest factor affecting premiums.
The most expensive states for auto repair shop insurance are:
- Michigan - highest costs due to expensive auto insurance environment and frequent claims
- Louisiana - high insurance costs driven by natural disaster exposure and legal climate
- Nevada - elevated costs from high vehicle values and urban crime rates
- California - expensive due to strict regulations and high property values
- New York - high costs from dense population and expensive real estate
The least expensive states for auto repair shop insurance are:
- Maine - lowest combined insurance and operational costs
- New Hampshire - minimal regulations and low claim frequencies
- Virginia - moderate regulations with competitive insurance markets
- Idaho - low population density and minimal natural disaster risk
- Vermont - small market with low crime and claim rates
Urban versus rural location creates additional variation within states. Chicago repair shops pay 40-60% more than rural Illinois shops, while Manhattan premiums can triple compared to upstate New York. Factors include crime rates, population density, local regulations, and historical claim patterns in your specific zip code.
Conclusion
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Readers are encouraged to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. We accept no liability for any actions taken based on the information provided.
Insurance costs represent a significant but manageable expense for auto repair shops, typically ranging from $5,000 to $25,000 annually depending on your business model and location.
Understanding these costs upfront helps you budget appropriately and avoid coverage gaps that could threaten your business. Start with mandatory coverage, add essential protection like garagekeepers insurance, and expand coverage as your auto repair business grows and generates more revenue.
Sources
- JJ Insurance - Auto Repair Shop Insurance Guide
- Enerpize - Business Insurance for Auto Repair Shops
- Insureon - Auto Repair Mechanics Insurance
- AutoLeap - Types of Insurance for Auto Repair Shops
- Kickstand Insurance - Workers Comp for Mechanics
- Alkeme Insurance - Top 10 Insurance Policies for Auto Repair
- JenCap Group - Garagekeepers Coverage Guide
- PIA Insurance - Garage Keepers Insurance Costs
- HowMuch.net - Auto Repair Shop Insurance Cost Analysis
- Next Insurance - General Liability Insurance Costs