What is the client retention rate for an insurance broker?

This article was written by our expert who is surveying the industry and constantly updating the business plan for an insurance broker.

Who wrote this content?

The Dojo Business Team

A team of financial experts, consultants, and writers

We're a team of finance experts, consultants, market analysts, and specialized writers dedicated to helping new entrepreneurs launch their businesses. We help you avoid costly mistakes by providing detailed business plans, accurate market studies, and reliable financial forecasts to maximize your chances of success from day one—especially in the insurance brokerage market.

What is the current annual client retention rate for insurance brokers?

Insurance brokerages typically maintain annual client retention rates between 80% and 88%, with the industry average settling around 84%.

Top-performing agencies consistently achieve retention rates between 93% and 95%, demonstrating that exceptional service and strategic client management can significantly outperform industry standards. These elite brokerages invest heavily in proactive communication, personalized service, and comprehensive renewal strategies.

The variation in retention rates across the industry reflects differences in service quality, product mix, client demographics, and the level of proactive engagement brokers maintain with their client base. Newer brokerages often struggle to reach the industry average in their first few years, while established firms with strong reputations and systems typically exceed it.

Understanding where your brokerage stands relative to these benchmarks is critical for assessing your competitive position and identifying areas for improvement in your client retention strategy.

How do insurance brokers calculate retention rate and ensure accuracy?

Insurance brokerages calculate retention rate by comparing the number of clients or policies retained over a specific period against those lost or canceled, while factoring in new business to prevent reporting distortions.

The calculation typically involves pulling data from your agency management system and dividing the number of clients at the end of a period (minus new clients acquired) by the number of clients at the start of that period. Most brokerages run these calculations monthly or on a rolling 12-month basis to track trends and identify seasonal patterns.

Ensuring accuracy requires cleaning up data anomalies such as duplicate policies, administrative cancellations that aren't true client departures, and policies that were consolidated rather than canceled. Many brokerages separate retention calculations by revenue rather than just policy count to get a more accurate picture of business health, since losing one high-value client impacts your bottom line more than losing several small accounts.

Leading brokerages use their policy and revenue data from management systems, cross-reference with financial records, and conduct regular audits to verify that their retention calculations reflect actual client behavior rather than administrative noise.

This is one of the strategies explained in our insurance broker business plan.

How long do clients typically stay with an insurance brokerage?

Clients generally remain with insurance brokerages for 4 to 7 years on average, though this varies significantly by product type and service quality.

Life insurance and property insurance clients tend to stay longer—often 7 to 10 years or more—because these products involve longer-term commitments and less frequent price shopping. Health insurance clients, on the other hand, may switch more frequently due to annual plan changes, price sensitivity, and changing personal circumstances like job transitions.

Top-performing brokerages that prioritize relationship-building and provide consistent value often retain clients for 9 years or longer. The key differentiator is proactive communication, regular policy reviews, and demonstrating ongoing value beyond the initial sale.

As a new insurance broker, you should plan for the reality that building a stable book of business takes time, and your average client tenure will increase as you develop stronger relationships and refine your service model.

What percentage of new clients stay after their first renewal?

First renewal retention rates typically range from 70% to 75% for average brokerages, with top performers achieving 80% or higher.

The first renewal cycle represents the most critical period for client retention, as this is when the largest drop-off occurs. Clients who make it past their first renewal are significantly more likely to remain with your brokerage for multiple years, making this early relationship-building period essential for long-term success.

The drop-off before first renewal often results from clients feeling they didn't receive adequate value during their initial year, experiencing buyer's remorse, or being approached by competitors offering lower rates. Brokerages that implement structured onboarding processes, schedule mid-term check-ins, and proactively reach out before renewal dates see substantially higher first-year retention.

As you build your insurance brokerage, focus intensely on the first 12 to 18 months of the client relationship—this investment pays dividends in long-term retention and referrals.

How does retention rate vary by insurance product type?

Retention rates differ significantly across product types, with life insurance showing the highest retention above 90%, health insurance typically ranging from 80% to 88%, and property and casualty insurance falling between 80% and 85%.

What is the retention rate difference between high-value clients and smaller accounts?

High-value clients show retention rates of 95% or higher, compared to smaller accounts that typically retain at rates closer to the industry average of 84% to 88%.

This disparity exists because premium clients receive more personalized attention, dedicated account management, proactive renewal consultations, and customized communication strategies. Brokerages naturally allocate more resources to their highest-revenue clients, resulting in stronger relationships and greater perceived value.

High-value clients also tend to have more complex insurance needs, which creates natural barriers to switching—they've invested time in the relationship and understand the value of working with a broker who knows their full situation. Additionally, these clients are often less price-sensitive and more focused on service quality and comprehensive coverage.

For your insurance brokerage, this means you should segment your client base and develop tiered service models that provide appropriate attention levels while still maintaining profitability across all client segments. Even smaller accounts deserve consistent service, but your high-value clients should receive white-glove treatment that justifies their loyalty.

You'll find detailed market insights in our insurance broker business plan, updated every quarter.

How do policy renewals, cross-selling, and upselling influence retention?

Policy renewals, cross-selling, and upselling are the three most powerful drivers of client retention in insurance brokerages.

Policy renewals represent the most critical retention touchpoint, as most cancellations occur at renewal time if clients don't perceive adequate value or receive poor service. Brokerages that implement proactive renewal review processes—reaching out 60 to 90 days before renewal dates—see significantly higher retention rates because they address concerns before clients begin shopping elsewhere.

Cross-selling additional policies to existing clients increases retention by creating multiple touchpoints and deepening the relationship. A client with both home and auto insurance through your brokerage is statistically much less likely to leave than a client with only one policy, because the complexity and inconvenience of switching multiple policies creates a natural retention barrier.

Upselling enhanced coverage or additional riders demonstrates ongoing value and positions you as a trusted advisor rather than just a transaction facilitator. Clients who see you proactively recommending coverage improvements as their life circumstances change are more likely to view the relationship as valuable and worth maintaining.

The combination of these three strategies creates a retention ecosystem where clients feel consistently engaged, see ongoing value, and face meaningful friction if they consider switching to a competitor.

How does insurance broker retention compare with industry averages over three years?

Over the past three years, insurance brokerage retention rates have remained remarkably stable at 83% to 84% industry-wide, while top-performing agencies consistently maintain rates above 93%.

This stability suggests that retention dynamics in the insurance brokerage industry are relatively mature and predictable, with competitive pressures and service standards largely offsetting each other. However, the consistent gap between average and top performers demonstrates that operational excellence and strategic client management create measurable competitive advantages.

Brokerages that have adopted proactive service models, invested in data-driven client management, implemented personalized renewal strategies, and leveraged technology for consistent communication have maintained their performance advantage even as market conditions evolved. The COVID-19 pandemic years (2020-2022) created some temporary disruption, but retention rates quickly returned to pre-pandemic levels.

For new insurance brokers entering the market, this three-year stability means you can rely on these benchmarks for business planning purposes, while also recognizing that reaching top-performer status requires intentional strategy execution rather than simply hoping market conditions will improve your retention rates.

What are the most common reasons insurance clients leave their broker?

The most common reasons insurance clients leave their broker include indifference or poor service (approximately 28% of departures), pricing concerns, better competitive offers, and lack of regular contact or personalized attention before renewal.

• Service indifference: About 28% of clients leave because they feel their broker doesn't care about their business or provide adequate attention. This is the single largest preventable cause of client churn in insurance brokerages.
• Lack of proactive communication: Approximately 65% of clients who leave never speak to their broker before canceling, indicating that many departures could be prevented through regular contact and relationship maintenance.
• Price sensitivity: While price is frequently cited as a reason for switching, it's often a symptom rather than the root cause—clients who feel they're receiving strong value and service are less likely to shop based solely on price.
• Better competitor offers: Aggressive marketing from direct-to-consumer insurers and competing brokers can lure clients away, especially if your relationship is weak or communication infrequent.
• Poor claims experience: Clients who experience difficult claims processes—even if the issue is with the insurance carrier rather than the broker—may blame their broker for not setting proper expectations or advocating effectively on their behalf.
• Life changes without broker awareness: Major life events like marriage, home purchase, new business, or retirement create opportunities for coverage updates, but if your client experiences these changes without hearing from you, they may seek out a new broker who seems more attentive.
• Inadequate coverage education: Clients who don't fully understand their coverage or why they need certain policies are more likely to see insurance as a commodity and make decisions based purely on price.

Research indicates that only 13% of insurance clients are truly loyal to their broker, meaning the vast majority are at risk of switching if they receive a compelling offer or experience service deficiencies.

What proactive measures do successful brokers take to re-engage at-risk clients?

Successful insurance brokers implement structured retention programs that include proactive annual renewal reviews, dedicated renewal calls, personalized multi-channel communications, customer nurture campaigns, satisfaction surveys, and loyalty incentives.

Proactive renewal reviews conducted 60 to 90 days before policy expiration allow brokers to address concerns, review coverage adequacy, and demonstrate value before clients begin shopping with competitors. These reviews should include market comparisons showing competitive pricing and coverage analysis identifying any gaps or redundancies in the client's current insurance portfolio.

Personalized communication strategies using email, SMS, phone calls, and direct mail ensure that clients receive consistent touchpoints throughout the policy year, not just at renewal time. Leading brokerages segment their client base and create communication cadences appropriate to each segment's value and needs.

Customer satisfaction surveys and Net Promoter Score measurements help identify at-risk clients before they cancel, allowing brokers to intervene with targeted retention efforts. When surveys reveal dissatisfaction, top-performing brokerages have protocols for immediate follow-up by senior team members to resolve issues and rebuild trust.

Staff training programs ensure that every team member understands the importance of retention, recognizes early warning signs of client dissatisfaction, and knows how to engage effectively to resolve concerns before they escalate to cancellation.

We cover this exact topic in the insurance broker business plan.

How do client satisfaction scores correlate with retention in insurance brokerages?

Higher client satisfaction scores and Net Promoter Scores (NPS) directly correlate with better retention rates, with brokerages maintaining high NPS typically reporting retention rates noticeably above the 84% industry average.

Client satisfaction measurement provides early warning signals of retention risk—clients who express dissatisfaction in surveys are statistically far more likely to cancel at renewal than those reporting high satisfaction. This makes satisfaction tracking one of your most valuable retention tools, as it allows you to identify and address issues proactively rather than reactively.

Net Promoter Score, which measures clients' willingness to recommend your brokerage to others, serves as a leading indicator of retention because promoters (those scoring 9-10) rarely leave, while detractors (those scoring 0-6) have significantly higher cancellation rates. Brokerages with NPS above 50 typically achieve retention rates in the 90%+ range.

The correlation exists because satisfaction and retention share common drivers: quality service, responsive communication, fair pricing, effective claims support, and demonstration of ongoing value. Measuring satisfaction gives you quantifiable data on how well you're delivering these retention drivers.

For your insurance brokerage, implementing quarterly satisfaction surveys with immediate follow-up protocols for negative responses should be a cornerstone of your retention strategy from day one.

What retention strategies have shown the most measurable impact recently?

The most impactful retention strategies in the past 12 months include proactive renewal reviews, automated personalized engagement campaigns, frequent satisfaction surveys with immediate follow-up on negative feedback, and staff training programs to improve service consistency.

Conclusion

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Readers are encouraged to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. We accept no liability for any actions taken based on the information provided.

Sources

1. Agency Brokerage - The Value of Customer Retention
2. Agency Performance Partners - Insurance Policy Retention
3. Agency Performance Partners - Average Retention Rate for Insurance Industry
4. KPI Tracker - Insurance Brokerage Key Performance Indicators
5. REVE Chat - Customer Retention in Insurance
6. Ease - Insurance Agency Client Retention
7. Agents Alliance - How Long Do You Keep Your Insurance Clients
8. Glassbox - Insurance Customer Retention Strategies