How profitable is an insurance brokerage firm?

Data provided here comes from our team of experts who have been working on business plan for an insurance brokerage firm. Furthermore, an industry specialist has reviewed and approved the final article.

insurance broker profitabilityWhat is the average profitability of an insurance brokerage firm, and what income can one expect from insurance sales?

Let's check together.

Revenue metrics for an insurance brokerage firm

How does an insurance brokerage firm generate income?

An insurance broker generates income by charging fees for helping customers find and purchase insurance policies.

What do insurance brokers sell, exactly?

Insurance brokers are intermediaries who sell insurance products and services on behalf of insurance companies to individuals and businesses.

They don't sell insurance policies directly, but rather act as liaisons between insurance buyers and insurers.

Insurance brokers work to understand the unique needs and risk profiles of their clients and then provide expert advice on selecting the most appropriate insurance coverage.

They help clients navigate the complex insurance market by researching and comparing policies from multiple insurance providers, presenting options that align with their clients' requirements, and negotiating terms and pricing.

Once a policy is selected, insurance brokers facilitate the purchasing process, including handling paperwork and payments.

Additionally, insurance brokers often provide ongoing support by assisting clients with claims processing, policy renewals, and adjustments as their needs change.

Essentially, insurance brokers sell the expertise and guidance needed to secure the right insurance protection tailored to their clients' specific circumstances.

What is the pricing model?

The pricing model of an insurance brokerage firm is central to how it generates revenue for its services in helping clients find and secure insurance coverage.

Insurance brokerage firms typically use one or a combination of the following pricing models

Commission-Based Model

The most common pricing model for insurance brokers is commission-based.

In this model, the broker earns a commission from the insurance company for each insurance policy sold or renewed.

Commissions are typically a percentage of the premium paid by the policyholder.

The specific commission rates can vary depending on the type of insurance (e.g., property and casualty, life, health) and the insurance company.

The commission percentage often ranges from 5% to 20% of the premium, with some variations based on factors like policy complexity and term length.


Some insurance brokerage firms charge clients a fee for their services instead of or in addition to earning commissions from insurance companies.

Fee-for-service models may involve hourly rates, flat fees, or retainer-based fees.

For example, clients might pay a one-time fee for a consultation or a periodic fee for ongoing risk management and advisory services. Fee-for-service arrangements are often used in commercial insurance or for specialized consulting services.

Combination Model

Many insurance brokerage firms use a combination of commission-based and fee-based compensation.

They may receive commissions for selling policies from certain insurance companies while charging fees for providing additional services, such as risk analysis, policy review, or claims management.

Profit-Sharing Arrangements

In some cases, insurance brokerage firms may enter into profit-sharing agreements with insurance companies.

These agreements allow brokers to share in the profits generated by policies they place with the insurance company.

Profit-sharing arrangements can provide an additional revenue source for brokers.

Volume-Based Bonuses

Insurance brokers may earn volume-based bonuses from insurance companies based on the total premiums or policies they bring to the insurer.

These bonuses are typically awarded when brokers meet or exceed specific production targets set by the insurance company.

Administrative or Service Fees

Brokers may charge administrative or service fees for tasks such as processing policy changes, handling claims, or providing policy-related services.

These fees are typically billed separately and are intended to cover the cost of administrative tasks rather than serving as the primary source of revenue.

business plan insurance agentWho are the customers of an insurance brokerage firm?

An insurance brokerage firm serves a wide variety of customers, ranging from individuals and families to businesses and organizations.

Which segments?

We've been working on many business plans for this sector. Here are the usual customer categories.

Customer Segment Description Preferences How to Find Them
Young Professionals Early-career individuals, tech-savvy, seeking affordable coverage. Convenient online processes, digital communication. Social media ads, tech-related events.
Families Parents with children, focused on comprehensive coverage. Family-oriented policies, coverage for dependents. School events, parenting forums.
Retirees Senior citizens, looking for retirement and health coverage. Healthcare benefits, retirement plans. Senior community centers, healthcare seminars.
Small Business Owners Entrepreneurs, need business and liability insurance. Customized business policies, liability coverage. Chamber of commerce events, business networks.
High-Net-Worth Individuals Affluent clients needing specialized coverage. Customized policies, high coverage limits. Private clubs, upscale events.

How much they spend?

In our comprehensive analysis of the financial dynamics within an insurance brokerage firm (when we were creating the business plan template), we've determined that clients generally spend between $500 to $2,000 annually on premiums. These figures fluctuate based on several factors including the type of insurance policies chosen, coverage limits, and individual risk assessments.

Insight into the industry indicates that the average duration a client stays with an insurance broker spans from 3 to 10 years. This period varies significantly, influenced by factors like customer satisfaction, changes in the client's needs, competitive pricing, and the ability of the brokerage to offer comprehensive solutions.

Calculating based on these parameters, the lifetime value of an average client at an insurance brokerage firm would range from $1,500 (3x500) to $20,000 (10x2,000). This calculation takes into account the total premiums collected over the span of the client's engagement with the broker, excluding operational costs and commission payouts.

With a broader perspective, it's reasonable to estimate that the average client contributes around $10,500 in revenue to an insurance brokerage firm over the course of their relationship.

(Disclaimer: the figures presented above serve as general estimations and may not reflect the precise revenue dynamics of your particular business context. Various factors, including market competition, client retention, and policy types, can influence actual values.)

Which type(s) of customer(s) to target?

It's something to have in mind when you're writing the business plan for your insurance brokerage firm.

The most profitable customers for an insurance brokerage firm are often small to medium-sized businesses.

They are highly profitable because they typically require a range of insurance policies, including liability, property, workers' compensation, and more, resulting in larger premiums and steady, ongoing business.

To target and attract these customers, the firm can utilize targeted marketing strategies such as online advertising, networking within business communities, and offering tailored insurance solutions that address their specific needs and risks.

To retain them, maintaining strong relationships through regular communication, conducting policy reviews to ensure their coverage remains relevant, and promptly addressing claims or concerns are crucial steps in retaining these profitable clients.

What is the average revenue of an insurance brokerage firm?

The average monthly revenue for an insurance brokerage firm can generally range from $5,000 to $50,000. This variance is due to factors such as the firm's size, location, client base, and the types of insurance policies it offers. Let's examine this in more detail.

You can also estimate your own revenue by considering these different profiles or by using a detailed financial plan tailored for an insurance brokerage firm.

Case 1: A small brokerage in a rural community

Average monthly revenue: $5,000

This type of brokerage firm is usually operated by a single broker or a small team. It primarily serves the local community and offers basic insurance policies, such as auto, home, and life insurance.

Due to its limited market reach and lower policy premiums in rural areas, the firm’s revenue potential remains limited. The brokerage may handle around 100 policies a month, with average earnings of $50 from each policy (considering new sales and renewals), making the monthly revenue approximately $5,000.

Case 2: A medium-sized brokerage in a suburban area

Average monthly revenue: $20,000

Medium-sized brokerage firms often operate in larger suburban areas and cater to a more extensive client base. These firms offer a wider variety of insurance products, potentially including health, travel, and specialized liability insurance, in addition to the standard policies.

With a more extensive market, such brokerages may handle up to 400 policies a month. Assuming they earn an average of $50 in commission per policy, their monthly revenue would be around $20,000. This size of a brokerage might also have additional revenue from consultation fees and offering custom insurance packages.

Case 3: A large, established brokerage in a major city

Average monthly revenue: $50,000

Large brokerage firms in major cities have access to a vast and diverse market. They handle complex insurance needs for both individuals and businesses, offering a wide array of specialized insurance products, possibly even international insurance policies.

These firms are well-staffed, often part of national or international networks, and equipped with the technology to provide sophisticated risk analysis and online services. They can easily handle over 1,000 policies a month.

With increased business and commercial clients, the average commission per policy can significantly increase, potentially averaging around $50 for standard policies and much higher for corporate or specialized ones. Thus, the firm's monthly revenue could easily reach or exceed $50,000. Diversified revenue streams, such as fees for risk management consulting or financial planning services, contribute to additional income.

It's important to note that these figures are simplified estimates and actual revenues can vary greatly based on numerous factors including the economic climate, competition, market demand, and regulatory environment.

business plan insurance brokerage firm

The profitability metrics of an insurance brokerage firm

What are the expenses of an insurance brokerage firm?

An insurance brokerage firm's expenses consist of broker commissions, insurance policies, office rent or lease payments, and marketing.

Category Examples of Expenses Average Monthly Cost (Range in $) Tips to Reduce Expenses
Office Rent Rental costs for office space $2,000 - $10,000 Consider sharing office space, working from home, or negotiating lower rent rates.
Salaries and Commissions Employee salaries, commissions, and bonuses $5,000 - $20,000 Optimize staff roles and responsibilities, align commissions with performance metrics, and consider outsourcing certain tasks.
Marketing and Advertising Advertising, website maintenance, and promotional materials $1,000 - $5,000 Focus on targeted digital marketing, measure marketing ROI, and utilize cost-effective advertising channels.
Technology and Software Software subscriptions, IT support, and office equipment $500 - $2,500 Opt for cost-effective software solutions, conduct regular equipment maintenance, and utilize cloud-based tools.
Client Acquisition Lead generation, client outreach, and networking expenses $500 - $2,000 Utilize online lead generation tools, attend industry events, and leverage existing client relationships for referrals.
Professional Development Continuing education and certification costs $200 - $1,000 Explore online courses and seek employer-sponsored training opportunities.
Compliance and Legal Fees Compliance-related expenses and legal fees $500 - $2,500 Stay updated on industry regulations, minimize compliance violations, and consult with legal experts for cost-effective solutions.
Insurance Professional liability insurance and business insurance $100 - $500 Shop for competitive insurance rates and maintain a safe and ethical practice to reduce insurance costs.
Miscellaneous Unforeseen expenses and contingencies $500 - $2,000 Maintain a contingency fund and budget for unexpected costs.

When is a an insurance brokerage firm profitable?

The breakevenpoint

An insurance brokerage firm becomes profitable when its total revenue exceeds its total fixed costs.

In simpler terms, it starts making a profit when the money it earns from selling insurance policies and perhaps other financial services becomes greater than the expenses it incurs for office space, employee salaries, marketing, and other operating costs.

This means that the insurance brokerage has reached a point where it covers all its fixed expenses and starts generating income, we call it the breakeven point.

Consider an example of an insurance brokerage firm where the monthly fixed costs typically amount to approximately $50,000.

A rough estimate for the breakeven point of an insurance brokerage, would then be around $50,000 (since it's the total fixed cost to cover), or selling insurance policies that could range significantly depending on the commission structure, the type of insurance sold, and the premiums associated with those policies. For instance, they might need to sell between 100 and 250 policies a month with average premiums ranging from $200 to $500, if they earn an average commission of around 20% per policy.

You have to know that this indicator can vary widely depending on factors such as location, operational efficiency, policy types, commission structures, operational costs, and competition. A large firm with numerous brokers would obviously have a higher breakeven point than a small firm with fewer overheads and a lean operation.

Curious about the profitability of your insurance brokerage? Try out our user-friendly financial plan crafted for insurance firms. Simply input your own assumptions, and it will help you calculate the amount you need to earn in order to run a profitable business.

Biggest threats to profitability

The biggest threats to profitability for an insurance brokerage firm can stem from a variety of factors.

Firstly, intense competition in the insurance market can lead to price wars and reduced commissions, squeezing profit margins.

Secondly, fluctuations in interest rates can impact investment income, a significant revenue source for brokers.

Additionally, regulatory changes and compliance requirements can increase operational costs and administrative burdens.

Lastly, shifts in consumer behavior and technology advancements may require substantial investments in digital infrastructure and customer service, adding to expenses.

These threats are often included in the SWOT analysis for an insurance brokerage firm.

What are the margins of an insurance brokerage firm?

Gross margins and net margins are critical financial metrics used to gauge the profitability of an insurance brokerage firm.

The gross margin reflects the difference between the revenue earned from selling insurance policies and the direct costs related to acquiring those policies, such as commissions paid to brokers, premium costs, and related fees.

Essentially, it's the profit remaining after deducting costs directly linked to the operational aspect of the insurance services, such as broker commissions, underwriting expenses, and premium taxes.

Net margin, however, accounts for all expenses borne by the brokerage, including indirect costs like administrative overhead, marketing, office space rent, and corporate taxes.

Net margin offers a comprehensive view of the brokerage's profitability by encompassing both direct and indirect expenses.

Gross margins

Insurance brokerages typically have an average gross margin ranging from 25% to 40%.

For instance, if your insurance brokerage firm earns $20,000 per month, your gross profit might be around 30% x $20,000 = $6,000.

Let's elucidate with an example:

Consider an insurance brokerage that sells policies totaling $10,000 in premiums.

However, the brokerage incurs direct costs for commissions, premium taxes, and underwriting fees.

Assuming these direct costs total $7,000, the brokerage's gross profit equates to $10,000 - $7,000 = $3,000.

Thus, the gross margin for the brokerage stands at $3,000 / $10,000 = 30%.

Net margins

Insurance brokerages generally achieve an average net margin within the range of 15% to 25%.

For simplicity, if your brokerage earns $20,000 per month, your net profit may hover around $4,000, representing 20% of the total revenue.

Continuing with our consistent example:

Imagine our insurance brokerage still accumulates $10,000 from policy sales. The direct costs were outlined at $7,000.

Furthermore, the brokerage undergoes various indirect expenses, including marketing campaigns, administrative costs, office rent, and legal compliance fees. Presuming these additional costs amount to $1,500.

After accounting for both direct and indirect costs, the brokerage's net profit tallies at $10,000 - $7,000 - $1,500 = $1,500.

Consequently, the net margin for the brokerage calculates to $1,500 / $10,000, resulting in 15%.

As an entrepreneur, comprehending the distinction between net margin and gross margin is pivotal, as net margin yields a more accurate insight into your insurance brokerage's actual profitability, encapsulating the entirety of costs and expenditures involved.

business plan insurance brokerage firm

At the end, how much can you make as an insurance brokerage firm owner?

Understanding that the net margin is the key to determining the profitability of your insurance brokerage is crucial. It reveals the percentage of total revenue that constitutes your profit after covering all operational expenses.

Your potential earnings hinge significantly on your business acumen and operational efficiency.

Struggling insurance broker

Makes $2,000 per month

If you set up a small insurance brokerage without much focus on client relations, workforce efficiency, or diverse policy offerings, your total revenue may stagnate around $10,000.

Furthermore, if expenses aren't kept in check, your net margin could be as low as 20%. Poor client engagement and limited services often lead to reduced market competitiveness.

This equates to you bringing home just $2,000 per month (20% of $10,000). It's a tough market, and this is an illustration of the income at the lower end of the spectrum.

Average insurance broker

Makes $10,000 per month

Now, if you're running a standard insurance brokerage, with attention to customer service, and offering a range of common insurance policies, things look brighter. You engage in regular marketing and enjoy decent customer loyalty, pushing your total revenue to about $50,000.

With prudent expense management and solid customer relations, your net margin could rise to around 25%.

This means your monthly take-home would be around $10,000 (25% of $40,000). This scenario represents a stable and sustainable business model.

Exceptional insurance broker

Makes $70,000 per month

As an owner who strives for excellence, you understand the importance of a diverse portfolio of insurance offerings, including niche policies. You invest in skilled workforce training, advanced CRM (Customer Relationship Management) systems, and aggressive marketing strategies.

Your efforts create robust client acquisition and retention, propelling your total revenue to an impressive $200,000.

Efficient operations, innovative services, and strategic partnerships enhance your net margin to about 35%.

Consequently, your monthly earnings skyrocket to approximately $70,000 (35% of $200,000). This tier reflects a thriving insurance brokerage that has mastered the balance between high revenue and controlled expenses.

May you reach this pinnacle of success! Achieving this feat starts with a comprehensive, forward-thinking business plan for your insurance brokerage, addressing both current market conditions and future growth opportunities.

business plan insurance agent
Back to blog