How much does insurance cost for a pet sitting business?

This article was written by our expert who is surveying the industry and constantly updating the business plan for a pet sitting business.

Our business plan for a pet sitting business will help you build a profitable project

Who wrote this content?

The Dojo Business Team

A team of financial experts, consultants, and writers

We're a team of finance experts, consultants, market analysts, and specialized writers dedicated to helping new entrepreneurs launch their businesses. We help you avoid costly mistakes by providing detailed business plans, accurate market studies, and reliable financial forecasts to maximize your chances of success from day one—especially in the pet sitting market.

What types of insurance do I legally need to run my pet sitting business?

You legally need general liability insurance and workers' compensation if you have employees.

General liability insurance is the foundation of pet sitting business protection, covering third-party claims for bodily injury and property damage. While not technically required by law in most states, many clients, property managers, and facilities demand proof of this coverage before allowing you to work with their pets or on their premises. Coverage typically starts at $139 annually for $1 million per occurrence.

Workers' compensation becomes legally mandatory the moment you hire your first employee in most U.S. states. This coverage protects your business from lawsuits related to workplace injuries while ensuring injured employees receive medical care and wage replacement. Annual costs range from $1,200 to $2,000+ depending on your state and payroll size.

Some municipalities may require business licenses that mandate specific insurance minimums. Always check local regulations as requirements vary significantly by location. Cities with higher pet ownership rates often have stricter insurance requirements for pet care professionals.

Without proper legal coverage, you risk business closure, hefty fines, and personal liability that could bankrupt your company.

Which optional insurance types should I seriously consider for my pet sitting business?

Professional liability, bonding, and animal bailee coverage are the three most valuable optional insurances for pet sitters.

Professional liability insurance protects against claims of negligence or errors in your service delivery. This becomes crucial when administering medications, handling special needs pets, or providing specialized care instructions. At $120-$360 annually, it's affordable protection against potentially devastating lawsuits from dissatisfied clients claiming your services harmed their pet.

Bonding (fidelity bonds) builds immediate trust with clients by protecting them against theft or property damage by you or your employees. A $10,000 bond costs just $100-$400 annually and significantly enhances your business credibility. Many high-end clients specifically seek bonded pet sitters.

Animal bailee coverage fills a critical gap in general liability policies by covering injury, illness, or death of pets in your care. Since pets are legally considered property, standard liability often excludes them. This coverage, available as an add-on for $24-$84 annually, provides $2,500-$5,000 in veterinary reimbursement.

We cover this exact topic in the pet sitting business plan.

How much should I budget monthly and annually for each type of pet sitting insurance?

Monthly insurance costs for pet sitting businesses range from $14 to $170+, with annual expenses between $139 and $4,000+ depending on coverage types and business size.

What coverage amounts work best for solo pet sitters versus larger operations?

Solo pet sitters need $1-2 million in general liability coverage, while team operations require $2-5 million with additional protections.

For solo operators, a general liability policy with $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate coverage provides adequate protection for most situations. This level covers typical incidents like dog bites, property damage during walks, or slip-and-fall accidents at client homes. Animal bailee coverage of $2,500-$5,000 per year handles most veterinary emergencies.

Team-based businesses face exponentially higher risks due to multiple employees, more clients, and expanded service areas. These operations need minimum $2 million per occurrence with $5 million aggregate limits. Workers' compensation becomes mandatory, and bonding coverage should increase proportionally with employee count—typically $25,000-$50,000 for teams of 5-10 sitters.

Multi-location businesses require separate coverage for each physical location, plus higher professional liability limits ($1-2 million) to protect against coordinated service failures. Commercial auto insurance with $1 million combined single limits becomes essential when employees drive company vehicles.

Coverage needs also scale with service complexity—businesses offering grooming, training, or overnight boarding need 50-100% higher limits than basic walking and feeding services.

How does my pet sitting business size directly impact insurance premiums?

Insurance premiums increase 40-60% for each employee added and 20-30% per additional service location.

Employee count drives the most significant premium increases in pet sitting businesses. Workers' compensation alone adds $1,200-$2,000 annually per full-time employee, while general liability premiums rise 15-25% for each additional staff member due to increased exposure. A solo operator paying $300 for general liability might pay $450 with two employees and $675 with five employees.

Client volume impacts premiums through revenue-based calculations. Insurers typically charge $0.50-$1.50 per $100 of gross revenue for general liability. A business earning $50,000 annually pays $250-$750, while one earning $200,000 pays $1,000-$3,000 for identical coverage limits.

Geographic expansion multiplies costs significantly. Each additional service location requires separate property coverage and potentially different liability limits based on local regulations. Operating across state lines often necessitates multiple policies, as insurance is state-regulated. Multi-state operations can see premiums increase 200-300% compared to single-location businesses.

Service complexity also affects size-related pricing. Businesses offering just walking pay 30-50% less than those adding grooming, training, or overnight care, regardless of employee count.

What factors cause the biggest swings in my pet sitting insurance costs?

Location, claims history, and services offered create premium variations of 200-400% between similar pet sitting businesses.

1. Geographic location: Urban areas with high litigation rates (California, New York) charge 150-200% more than rural Midwest locations. A policy costing $300 in Kansas might cost $750 in Los Angeles.
2. Claims history: One claim increases premiums 25-50%; two claims can double costs or result in coverage denial. Even claims under deductible amounts affect future rates.
3. Service mix: Basic walking/feeding operations pay base rates. Adding grooming increases premiums 30-40%, training adds 20-30%, and exotic animal care adds 50-75%.
4. Coverage limits: Doubling liability limits from $1M to $2M typically increases premiums just 15-20%, making higher coverage cost-effective.
5. Business experience: New businesses pay 20-30% more than those with 3+ years of clean operating history. Some insurers require 2 years minimum experience for certain coverages.

Should I buy bundled pet sitting insurance or separate policies?

Bundled policies save 20-30% compared to separate coverage and simplify claims processing for pet sitting businesses.

Business Owner's Policies (BOPs) combine general liability and property coverage at significant discounts. A typical BOP costs $550 annually, while purchasing these coverages separately might total $750-$850. BOPs also include business interruption insurance and often data breach coverage at no extra charge—valuable additions for modern pet sitting operations.

Bundle advantages extend beyond price. Single-source policies mean one renewal date, one payment, and one point of contact for claims. This simplification becomes crucial during stressful claim situations. Coverage gaps between policies disappear, eliminating finger-pointing between insurers about which policy applies.

Separate policies only make sense for highly specialized operations needing unusual coverage limits or exclusions. For example, businesses focusing exclusively on exotic animals might need specialized liability policies unavailable in standard bundles. Companies with multiple locations across state lines might require separate policies due to regulatory differences.

Most pet sitters benefit from starting with a BOP and adding endorsements for professional liability, animal bailee, and other specific needs. This approach balances comprehensive coverage with cost efficiency.

Which insurance companies offer the best coverage and service for pet sitting businesses?

Pet Care Insurance, Pet Sitters Associates, and Business Insurers of the Carolinas consistently rank highest for specialized pet sitting coverage.

How do pet sitting insurance costs vary across different states and countries?

Insurance costs vary by 300% across U.S. states, with California and New York charging triple the rates of Wyoming or Montana.

State-level variations stem from litigation culture, veterinary costs, and regulatory requirements. California pet sitters pay $600-$1,200 for basic general liability due to high lawsuit frequency and expensive veterinary care. Texas, Florida, and New York follow closely with premiums 50-75% above national averages. Conversely, Midwest and Mountain states offer coverage for $150-$400 annually.

International differences prove even more dramatic. UK pet sitters enjoy lower base premiums (£150-£400) but face higher required coverage limits (£1-5 million public liability). Australian operators pay similar rates but must navigate state-specific regulations. Canadian businesses face 20-30% higher costs than U.S. equivalents due to stricter liability laws.

Urban versus rural disparities within states can equal interstate differences. Manhattan pet sitters pay 200% more than upstate New York operators. Los Angeles premiums exceed Central Valley rates by 150%. These variations reflect both claim frequency and average settlement amounts.

You'll find detailed market insights in our pet sitting business plan, updated every quarter.

Which insurance add-ons should I skip to keep costs reasonable?

Skip cyber liability, high-value equipment coverage, and business income insurance unless your pet sitting operation specifically requires them.

1. Cyber liability ($300-$1,000/year): Unnecessary unless storing credit cards or extensive digital client records. Basic data breach coverage in BOPs suffices for most pet sitters using simple scheduling apps.
2. Equipment coverage over $5,000: Most pet sitters need minimal equipment. Unless using specialized grooming tools or transport vehicles, standard $2,500 coverage handles leashes, crates, and basic supplies.
3. Business income insurance: Only valuable for businesses with physical locations or high fixed costs. Home-based sitters can resume operations immediately after most covered losses.
4. Commercial auto (if unnecessary): Personal auto policies with business use endorsements cost 70% less than commercial policies. Only needed for logo-wrapped vehicles or employee drivers.
5. Excessive liability limits: Coverage beyond $2M rarely triggers for pet sitting claims. The premium jump from $2M to $5M (30-40% increase) rarely justifies the protection.

How do insurance costs change as my pet sitting business matures?

Insurance costs typically decrease 15-25% after three claim-free years, then increase gradually with business expansion.

New businesses face "startup penalties" of 20-30% higher premiums due to unknown risk profiles. After establishing three years of clean operations, insurers offer "preferred risk" discounts. A pet sitter paying $500 initially might pay $375-$425 by year four with identical coverage. Some insurers provide 5% annual loyalty discounts up to 25% maximum.

Growth phases trigger cost increases despite good history. Adding employees immediately adds workers' compensation costs ($100-$170 monthly per employee). Expanding service areas increases liability exposure, raising premiums 10-15% per new territory. Revenue growth directly impacts liability premiums through revenue-based rating.

Claims dramatically alter this trajectory. One significant claim can increase premiums 50-100% at renewal, erasing years of good-behavior discounts. Multiple claims might force businesses into high-risk pools with 200-300% standard rates. Some insurers implement three-year "lookback" periods, meaning one bad year affects costs for 36 months.

Mature businesses (10+ years) often see slight annual increases (2-5%) reflecting inflation and market conditions, assuming stable operations and clean claims history.

Are there pet sitting associations offering discounted insurance programs?

NAPPS and PSI members access group insurance rates 20-40% below individual market pricing through preferred provider relationships.

Conclusion

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Readers are encouraged to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. We accept no liability for any actions taken based on the information provided.

Sources

1. How to Start an LLC - Business Insurance for Pet Sitters
2. Time - Pet Sitting Insurance Guide
3. Insureon - Pet Care Business Insurance Cost
4. Pet Care Insurance
5. Time to Pet - Definitive Guide to Pet Sitting Insurance
6. Superscript - Pet Sitters Insurance
7. Pet Sit LLC - Pet Business Insurance Options
8. Lewis McCann - Pet Sitting Insurance Cost
9. The Zebra - Pet Insurance Costs by State
10. Pet Business Insurance - Complete Cost Guide 2025