How profitable are auto repair shops?

This article was written by our expert who is surveying the industry and constantly updating the business plan for an auto repair shop.

Who wrote this content?

The Dojo Business Team

A team of financial experts, consultants, and writers

We're a team of finance experts, consultants, market analysts, and specialized writers dedicated to helping new entrepreneurs launch their businesses. We help you avoid costly mistakes by providing detailed business plans, accurate market studies, and reliable financial forecasts to maximize your chances of success from day one—especially in the auto repair shop market.

How we created this content 🔎📝

At Dojo Business, we know the auto repair market inside out—we track trends and market dynamics every single day. But we don't just rely on reports and analysis. We talk daily with local experts—entrepreneurs, investors, and key industry players. These direct conversations give us real insights into what's actually happening in the market.
To create this content, we started with our own conversations and observations. But we didn't stop there. To make sure our numbers and data are rock-solid, we also dug into reputable, recognized sources that you'll find listed at the bottom of this article.
You'll also see custom infographics that capture and visualize key trends, making complex information easier to understand and more impactful. We hope you find them helpful! All other illustrations were created in-house and added by hand.
If you think we missed something or could have gone deeper on certain points, let us know—we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

What are the typical monthly and yearly gross revenues for small, mid-sized, and large auto repair shops in the U.S.?

Auto repair shop revenues vary dramatically based on size, with small shops earning $68,000 to $300,000 annually while large operations can reach $2.5 million in yearly revenue.

Small auto repair shops, typically operating as sole proprietorships with 1-2 service bays, generate approximately $68,000 per year on the lower end, though well-managed small shops can reach up to $300,000 annually. These shops usually handle basic maintenance and simple repairs, serving local communities with personalized service.

Mid-sized auto repair shops represent about 38% of the market and generate between $500,000 and $1.2 million annually. These operations typically have 3-5 service bays, employ multiple technicians, and offer a broader range of services including diagnostics and specialized repairs. Their monthly revenue ranges from approximately $42,000 to $100,000.

Large auto repair shops, including franchises and well-established independent operations, achieve annual revenues between $1.2 million and $2.5 million. These facilities often have 6 or more service bays, advanced diagnostic equipment, and specialized departments for different types of repairs. Monthly revenues for large shops typically range from $100,000 to over $200,000.

Geographic location significantly impacts these revenue figures, with shops in high-cost areas like California commanding higher labor rates and consequently generating more revenue per repair order.

What is the average number of vehicles serviced per day or per week, and what is the average ticket size per service?

Auto repair shops typically service 5 to 15 vehicles daily, with average ticket sizes ranging from $200 to $838 depending on the type of service performed.

The break-even point for most auto repair shops requires servicing approximately 67 vehicles per month, which translates to roughly 3-4 vehicles per day for a minimal operation. However, profitable shops usually handle significantly more volume, with small shops averaging 5-8 vehicles daily and larger operations servicing 12-20 vehicles per day.

Average ticket sizes vary considerably based on the service mix offered. Basic maintenance services like oil changes typically generate tickets around $80, while more complex repairs can reach $754 to $850 for services like alternator replacement. The overall average ticket size across all services ranges from $200 for simple maintenance-focused shops to $838 for shops specializing in complex repairs.

Weekly volume typically ranges from 25-35 vehicles for small shops to 60-100 vehicles for larger operations. Shops that focus on quick services like oil changes may handle higher daily volumes but with lower ticket averages, while those specializing in complex diagnostics and repairs handle fewer vehicles but generate significantly higher revenue per customer.

Successful shops optimize their service mix to balance volume and ticket size, ensuring they maintain steady cash flow while maximizing profitability per repair order.

Which services generate the highest margins and which ones are most frequently requested?

Diagnostic and electrical services generate the highest profit margins at 50-65%, while oil changes and tire services are the most frequently requested despite having lower margins.

Service Category	Profit Margin	Frequency/Demand	Key Characteristics
Diagnostics/Electrical	50-65%	High (tech complexity)	Requires specialized skills and equipment, high labor content, minimal parts cost
Brake Repairs	40-50%	High (safety-critical)	Regular maintenance need, safety-focused customers willing to pay premium
Tire Services	30-40%	Very High (25% need replacement)	High turnover, seasonal demand spikes, volume-based profitability
Engine Repairs	35-45%	Medium	Complex repairs, high ticket values, longer service times
Transmission Services	40-55%	Medium	Specialized knowledge required, high-value repairs, longer customer relationships
Oil Changes	10-30%	Most Frequent	High volume, quick turnaround, customer acquisition tool, upselling opportunities
Air Conditioning	45-60%	Seasonal (Summer)	Seasonal revenue spike, specialized equipment, refrigerant markup opportunities

You'll find detailed market insights on service profitability in our auto repair shop business plan, updated every quarter.

What are the standard labor rates per hour in different regions, and how many billable hours per technician can be realistically expected?

Labor rates vary significantly by region, ranging from $75 per hour in lower-cost areas to $175 per hour in premium markets like California, with technicians typically generating 3.5+ billable hours per repair order.

Regional labor rate variations reflect local economic conditions and market demand. States like Mississippi average around $110 per hour, while California commands $155 to $175 per hour. These rates directly impact shop profitability, as labor typically represents the highest-margin revenue stream for auto repair shops.

Technician productivity is measured in billable hours per repair order rather than total daily hours. Successful shops target 3.5 or more billable hours per repair order, though individual technicians can work 9-12 hours daily. The key metric is efficiency - how many of those working hours can be billed to customers versus non-productive time.

Labor efficiency depends heavily on workflow optimization, proper scheduling, and having the right mix of simple and complex jobs. Shops that excel at scheduling can achieve higher billable hour ratios by minimizing downtime between jobs and ensuring technicians have consistent work queues.

The most profitable shops focus on maximizing both labor rates and billable hour efficiency, often achieving this through specialized services that command premium rates while maintaining steady workflow through effective customer scheduling and service mix optimization.

What are the most common recurring fixed costs for an auto repair shop and what are their average amounts per month?

Auto repair shops face monthly fixed costs ranging from $3,000 to $25,000, with rent, insurance, utilities, and equipment being the primary expense categories.

Fixed Cost Category	Monthly Range	Key Factors Affecting Cost
Rent/Lease	$1,500 - $15,000	Location, square footage, number of bays, regional real estate costs
Insurance (Liability, Property)	$400 - $1,250	Coverage limits, claims history, number of employees, location risk factors
Utilities (Electric, Water, Gas)	$500 - $1,500	Facility size, equipment usage, local utility rates, energy efficiency
Software/Technology	$1,000 - $5,000	Management software, diagnostic tools, payment processing, marketing platforms
Equipment Leases	$800 - $3,000	Lifts, diagnostic equipment, specialty tools, financing terms
Professional Services	$300 - $1,200	Accounting, legal, consulting, waste disposal, security services
Marketing/Advertising	$500 - $2,000	Local advertising, digital marketing, promotional materials, website maintenance

This is one of the strategies explained in our auto repair shop business plan.

What are the typical variable costs per job, such as parts, shop supplies, and outsourced services, and how do they impact overall margins?

Variable costs per job primarily consist of parts (marked up 20-30%) and shop supplies (2.9% of labor), significantly impacting overall margins depending on the service mix and procurement efficiency.

Parts represent the largest variable cost component, typically accounting for 30-50% of the total repair ticket value before markup. Auto repair shops generally apply a 20-30% markup on parts, though this can vary based on part type, supplier relationships, and local market conditions. High-volume shops often negotiate better wholesale pricing, improving their parts margins.

Shop supplies include consumables like oil, filters, cleaning materials, and small hardware items. These costs average approximately 2.9% of labor charges, meaning a shop with $1,000 in labor revenue can expect roughly $29 in shop supply costs. Efficient inventory management and bulk purchasing can help control these expenses.

Outsourced services such as machine shop work, specialized repairs, or hazardous waste disposal typically add 5-10% to specific job costs. Some shops build these costs into their service pricing, while others pass them through directly to customers with a modest markup.

The impact on overall margins depends heavily on service mix - diagnostic and electrical work with minimal parts requirements maintain higher margins, while parts-heavy repairs like transmission rebuilds operate on thinner margins but often generate higher absolute profit dollars due to larger ticket sizes.

What is the typical gross profit margin and net profit margin for auto repair shops by size, and what ranges are considered healthy?

Auto repair shops typically achieve gross profit margins of 50-65% on labor and 20-30% on parts, with healthy net profit margins ranging from 10-20% depending on shop size and operational efficiency.

Small auto repair shops generally operate with net profit margins of 10-15%, as they often struggle with economies of scale but benefit from lower overhead and more personalized service. These shops must focus on high-margin services and efficient operations to maintain profitability.

Medium-sized shops typically achieve net profit margins of 15-20%, benefiting from better purchasing power, more efficient utilization of fixed costs, and the ability to offer specialized services. Their larger customer base and diverse service offerings provide more stable revenue streams.

Large auto repair shops can achieve net profit margins of 20-25% or higher, leveraging economies of scale, advanced management systems, and optimized workflows. However, they also face challenges with increased complexity and higher staffing costs that must be carefully managed.

Healthy margin ranges are considered 10% minimum for sustainability, 15-20% for strong performance, and 20%+ for excellent operations. Shops consistently operating below 10% net margin often struggle with long-term viability and should examine their pricing, cost structure, and operational efficiency.

How does profitability evolve with scale — does higher volume necessarily lead to better margins or does it introduce new inefficiencies?

Higher volume can improve profitability through economies of scale, but it often introduces operational complexities that require careful management to avoid reducing margins through inefficiencies.

Economies of scale benefit larger auto repair shops through better purchasing power on parts and supplies, more efficient utilization of fixed costs like rent and equipment, and the ability to specialize technicians for improved efficiency. Large shops can also invest in advanced diagnostic equipment and management software that smaller operations cannot justify.

However, increased volume introduces several potential inefficiencies including overtime labor costs when demand exceeds capacity, inventory management challenges that can lead to parts obsolescence or stockouts, and communication breakdowns in larger teams. Quality control becomes more difficult as volume increases, potentially leading to rework and customer satisfaction issues.

The key to maintaining margins while scaling lies in implementing proper systems and processes before volume increases overwhelm existing capabilities. This includes investing in management software, establishing clear workflow procedures, and training staff to handle increased complexity.

Many successful shops find that moderate growth with careful attention to operational efficiency produces better long-term profitability than rapid expansion that strains systems and reduces service quality. The optimal balance varies by market conditions and management capabilities.

How much do staffing costs represent as a percentage of revenue, and how can this be optimized without sacrificing service quality?

Staffing costs should not exceed 35% of revenue for healthy auto repair shop operations, with optimization achieved through cross-training, efficient scheduling, and performance-based compensation structures.

The 35% payroll threshold includes all labor-related expenses such as wages, benefits, payroll taxes, and training costs. Shops exceeding this percentage often struggle with profitability and should examine their staffing structure, productivity levels, and pricing strategies. High-performing shops typically maintain payroll costs between 25-30% of revenue.

Cross-training technicians to handle multiple service types improves flexibility and reduces the need for specialized staff during slower periods. This approach allows shops to maintain service quality while optimizing labor costs by ensuring consistent productivity across different service demands.

Efficient scheduling systems help maximize billable hours per technician while minimizing downtime. Digital scheduling tools can optimize appointment booking, reduce gaps between jobs, and ensure proper workload distribution among staff members.

Performance-based compensation structures align employee incentives with shop profitability goals. This can include productivity bonuses, commission structures for certain services, or profit-sharing arrangements that encourage efficiency without compromising quality standards.

What are the most effective strategies to improve profitability in an auto repair shop — such as upselling, cross-selling, workflow efficiency, or tech investments?

The most effective profitability strategies combine systematic upselling and cross-selling with workflow optimization and strategic technology investments to maximize both revenue per customer and operational efficiency.

1. **Systematic Upselling and Cross-Selling Programs**: Implement structured inspection processes that identify additional service needs during routine maintenance. Train technicians to document and communicate findings professionally, leading to natural upselling opportunities without aggressive sales tactics.2. **Digital Inspection and Communication Tools**: Invest in digital inspection software that allows technicians to photograph and document vehicle conditions, creating visual evidence that helps customers understand repair needs and builds trust in recommended services.3. **Workflow Optimization Systems**: Implement lean management principles to eliminate waste in processes, reduce vehicle turnaround times, and maximize technician productivity through better job sequencing and parts availability.4. **Preventive Maintenance Programs**: Develop subscription-based maintenance programs that create recurring revenue streams while building customer loyalty and providing predictable cash flow.5. **Inventory Management Technology**: Use automated inventory systems to optimize parts purchasing, reduce carrying costs, and minimize stockouts that can delay repairs and reduce customer satisfaction.

We cover this exact topic in the auto repair shop business plan.

How do seasonal patterns affect revenue and profitability, and what adjustments should shops make during high or low seasons?

Auto repair shops experience significant seasonal revenue fluctuations, with winter and summer peaks requiring strategic service mix adjustments and marketing initiatives to maximize profitability throughout the year.

Winter months typically generate higher revenue through battery replacements, tire services, heating system repairs, and weather-related damage. Shops should stock appropriate inventory, train staff on seasonal services, and implement proactive marketing campaigns targeting winter preparation and emergency repairs.

Summer brings increased demand for air conditioning services, pre-vacation inspections, and tire rotations. Successful shops promote summer travel preparation packages and AC system maintenance to capture this seasonal demand. This period also sees increased general maintenance as customers prepare for vacation travel.

Spring and fall represent transition periods where shops can focus on maintenance services, inspections, and preparation for the upcoming extreme weather seasons. These periods are ideal for promotional campaigns targeting routine maintenance and system checks.

Revenue optimization strategies include developing seasonal service packages, adjusting marketing messages to match seasonal needs, managing inventory levels to support seasonal demand spikes, and cross-training staff to handle different service types as demand patterns shift throughout the year.

What are the average EBITDA and cash flow figures for a well-run shop, and how does this translate to potential owner income or ROI if the shop is owner-operated?

Well-run auto repair shops typically achieve EBITDA margins of 15-25%, translating to owner incomes of $50,000 to $150,000 annually for mid-sized operations, with ROI depending on initial investment and financing structure.

EBITDA calculations for auto repair shops include earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, providing insight into operational cash generation capability. The 15-25% range reflects efficient operations with proper cost controls and effective revenue management.

Owner income varies significantly based on shop size and owner involvement level. Owner-operators of small shops might earn $50,000-$80,000 annually, while owners of larger operations can achieve $100,000-$150,000 or more. These figures assume the owner takes a market-rate salary for their management role, with additional income coming from business profits.

Cash flow differs from EBITDA due to working capital requirements, debt service, and capital expenditures. Auto repair shops typically maintain positive operating cash flow but require ongoing investment in equipment and facility maintenance that affects available cash for owner distributions.

Return on investment calculations depend heavily on initial capital requirements, which can range from $75,000 for a small operation to $500,000+ for a large facility. Well-managed shops often achieve 20-35% ROI, though this varies based on financing structure, local market conditions, and operational efficiency levels.

Conclusion

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Readers are encouraged to consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions. We accept no liability for any actions taken based on the information provided.

Sources

1. Sharp Sheets - How Profitable is an Auto Repair Shop
2. Ratchet and Wrench - The Average Shop in 2022
3. ProBuilt Steel - Profit and Cost of Auto Repair Shops
4. AutoLeap - Most Profitable Auto Repair Services
5. AutoLeap - Average Automotive Repair Labor Rates by State
6. Identifix - Average Profit Margin for Auto Repair Shops
7. Cheema Auto - Are Auto Repair Shops Profitable 2025
8. Elite Worldwide - Shop Payroll as Percentage of Sales
9. FinModelsLab - Auto Repair Shop Operating Costs
10. Business Plan Templates - Vehicle Repair Shop Owner Income